The “Worst-Case Scenario”

Home » Blog » Articles » Horse Training

To Win on the Trail, Prepare for the Worst

by Raye Lochert


There is a popular board game called “The Worst-Case Scenario.” The object of the game is to successfully navigate unexpected and dangerous scenarios. In one version, the winning player will not only finish with the most gold tokens, they must keep the most body parts. I think a useful game for equestrians might be called “Worst-Case Scenario—Trail Riding Edition.” Players would win by staying on the trail, gathering gold “sanity” tokens and, of course, keeping all their body parts!

Trail riding is the most popular thing to do with horses. More people are on the trail than all the competition events combined. Why? We love the relaxation of a scenic ride. As do LOTS of cyclists, hikers, dog walkers, and campers. With all these people sharing space there is bound to be some congestion, frustration, or worse. With a bit of forethought and preparation, you can be ready for the “worst-case scenario,” and maybe help keep someone else safe, too.

Photo credit Raye Lochert

A sensitive flight animal, horses are usually aware of something well before it actually spooks them. This is usually when we ask them for their full attention and, by then, it is too late. You may be chatting with a friend or day dreaming when your horse reacts. By then it is too late to ask them to pay attention. To avoid the unpleasant, we must ride proactively using an ongoing, relaxed communication with our horse that keeps his focus on us. How do we accomplish this? With controlled riding. 

An arena is a great place to practice the moves and cues you need your horse to understand when it counts. For me, that includes a horse that collects, turns left and right, stops and backs up with ease—the “basics.” If my horse will do these five things easily and with little pressure in the arena then I can prepare for the trail and the possibility of the worst case scenario. 

How does one safely transition from the relative quiet of an arena to the unpredictability of the trail? By adding speed. With speed comes emotion—in both horse and rider. With this in mind, I practice my basic moves at speed. First I start with a walk, then a trot and then I practice at a lope. The faster I go the more the emotional level rises in the horse, lowering his performance. In the arena I can work on this and learn to control it more effectively. Let’s consider the stop. In the arena I work on my stops at the walk first. As soon as I increase the speed to the trot the level of performance in the stop goes down. Now I can return to the walk and work my way up to the trot again. Soon the horse will stop at the trot as well as they do at the walk, if not better. Once I can stop my horse 100% of the time at the trot softly and using the hindquarters I increase my speed to a lope. I do not expect the horse to stop as well at the lope as when they were trotting.

When I can do the basics with ease in the arena, I move outdoors. This is an area such as a pasture or even a quiet dirt road. Just being in a different place is enough to raise a horse’s emotions. When I have control in this outside environment I move to the park. When riding my horse in the park, I ask for the basics whenever I feel the horse’s attention is wandering. For example, let’s say my horse notices a mountain biker. When his attention diverts from me I ask him to collect up. This will get him to lower his head. As the bicyclist approaches, I will ask him to move his shoulders to the right or left. While we pass I talk to the bicyclist and keep asking my horse for a response to some cue. If I can keep my horse focused on listening to me by purposely distracting him he has less time to pay attention to the object of his fear.

After a while your horse will become more accustomed to the distractions of the trail and your responses will grow with practice, adding a level of confidence that will be noticed by your horse. A win-win situation. By preparing for the worst you actually set yourself up for the best, all while preserving you and your horse’s sanity (not to mention your body parts!). Remember to enjoy your horse.


Photo credit NWHS

Raye Lochert is a graduate of the John Lyons Certification program. Using his education, plus his own methods and unique way of teaching, he has developed a humane and constantly evolving program focused on the safety and success of both horse and rider. Working with horses and people of all levels and disciplines in a safe, fun and comfortable environment, Raye Lochert offers a very effective method of communication with horses that enables people to overcome road blocks and increase their enjoyment of their horse. At Raye Lochert Horsemanship, Raye and Sharon Lochert work hard to create an environment where people feel challenged yet safe. “It is like attending the University of the Horse,” says longtime student C.S. Noel. Learn more at


Published May 2013 Issue

Thank you for supporting the businesses that support The Northwest Horse Source

This content sponsored by:
This content sponsored by:
This content sponsored by:

Leave a Comment

Join the conversation:

Select a list(s):

Check out the Magazine!

The Northwest Horse Source Magazine